ED Medication Dosing: Sildenafil vs Tadalafil, Written Out Properly

ED Medication Dosing: Sildenafil vs Tadalafil, Written Out Properly

The exact FDA-label dosing for sildenafil and tadalafil: starting doses, timing, food rules, who starts lower, and how to choose between as-needed and daily.

The short version

Both first-line ED medications are generics that work the same way and differ mainly in how long they last. Sildenafil (generic Viagra) starts at 50 mg taken as needed about an hour before sex and lasts roughly an evening. [1] Tadalafil (generic Cialis) starts at 10 mg as needed and keeps working up to 36 hours, or can be taken as a small 2.5 to 5 mg tablet every day so there is nothing to time at all. [2]

A prescription is more than a drug name, and "sildenafil 50 mg" on its own is not a plan. Below is the full dosing picture the way a provider actually writes it: dose, route, timing, maximum frequency, what moves the dose up or down, and who needs to start lower.

Sildenafil, written out

The standard start: sildenafil 50 mg, one tablet by mouth, as needed, about 1 hour before sexual activity. It can be taken anywhere from 30 minutes to 4 hours before. Maximum one dose per day. [1]

Adjustment: based on effect and side effects, the dose moves up to 100 mg or down to 25 mg. [1] These are the only three strengths on the label; there is no benefit to splitting toward in-between numbers.

Food and alcohol: the label allows it with or without food, but a heavy, high-fat meal slows absorption and can blunt or delay the effect, so a lighter stomach works faster. [1] Moderate alcohol did not dangerously drop blood pressure in the label's interaction study, but heavy drinking impairs erections on its own and adds to lightheadedness. [1]

Who starts at 25 mg instead: men over 65, men with liver disease such as cirrhosis, men with severe kidney impairment, men taking alpha-blockers (tamsulosin, doxazosin and similar, and only once the alpha-blocker dose is stable), and men on strong CYP3A4 inhibitors such as ketoconazole or erythromycin. [1] On ritonavir, the cap is stricter: 25 mg, and no more than one dose in 48 hours. [1]

Tadalafil, written out

As needed: tadalafil 10 mg, one tablet by mouth before anticipated sexual activity, maximum one dose per day. Adjust to 20 mg or down to 5 mg based on response. Do not split the tablet. [2] The effect lasts up to 36 hours, which is the practical difference: one Friday tablet can cover the weekend. [2]

Once daily: tadalafil 2.5 mg by mouth, once daily at about the same time every day, regardless of when sex happens. Increase to 5 mg if needed. [2] Daily dosing suits men who are sexually active more than about twice a week, men who hate planning, and men who also have urinary symptoms from an enlarged prostate, which tadalafil 5 mg daily is separately approved to treat. [2]

Food: no food effect. Tadalafil works the same with or without a meal. [2]

Kidney and liver limits: with moderate kidney impairment the as-needed start drops to 5 mg with a 10 mg maximum every 48 hours; with severe impairment or dialysis the ceiling is 5 mg every 72 hours and daily dosing is not recommended. With liver disease the as-needed cap is 10 mg, and severe liver disease rules it out. [2]

Choosing between them honestly

  • Sildenafil. Starting dose 50 mg, taken about 1 hour before sex, effect lasting several hours. A lighter stomach works faster. Best fit: occasional, planned. [1]
  • Tadalafil as needed. Starting dose 10 mg, taken before anticipated sex, effective up to 36 hours, no food effect. Best fit: spontaneity across a weekend. [2]
  • Tadalafil daily. 2.5 mg at the same time every day, continuous coverage, no food effect. Best fit: frequent activity, no planning, prostate symptoms. [2]

Neither drug is stronger than the other in any way that matters at equivalent doses; head-to-head preference studies mostly track lifestyle fit, and men switched from sildenafil to tadalafil in trials largely did fine on either. [3] Cost differences between the generics are small. What is worth paying attention to is the trial-and-adjust process, not the brand mythology.

The rules that apply to both

  • Nitrates, never. Any nitrate, regular or as-needed, is an absolute contraindication with either drug. [1][2]
  • Riociguat, never. Same mechanism problem. [1][2]
  • Alpha-blockers, carefully. Stable alpha-blocker dose first, lowest ED-pill dose to start. [1][2]
  • One dose per day, full stop. A failed attempt is not fixed by a second tablet the same night. [1][2] It is fixed at follow-up, by an adjusted plan. Give any dose at least 4 fair attempts before calling it a failure. [4]

If the adjusted dose still is not working, the next steps are real and covered in what to do when ED pills do not work. Before your first tablet, read the first-dose briefing, and know the warning signs.

What it costs with Well Revolution

$80 for the Limited Treatment Plan. If approved, you will receive a 90 day treatment plan with 7 days a week support. Perfect for first time patients who are trying it out.

Or $90 for the Unlimited Membership. If approved, you will receive a full year of care with 7 days a week support, plus unlimited prescriptions, lab tests, imaging orders, letters and referrals with same day care, cancel anytime, no fees. Perfect for established patients looking for full care.

Getting started with Well Revolution

A licensed US provider reviews your health history in chat, same day, and writes the dose that fits your medications, age, kidneys, and liver rather than a one-size template. Dose adjustments afterward are part of the care, not a new fee. Message us and we confirm coverage in your state. The full process is in how to get an ED prescription online.

References

  1. Viagra (sildenafil citrate) prescribing information. Pfizer, via FDA DailyMed. DailyMed
  2. Cialis (tadalafil) prescribing information. Eli Lilly, via FDA DailyMed. DailyMed
  3. Stroberg P, et al. Switching patients with erectile dysfunction from sildenafil citrate to tadalafil. 2003. PubMed 14693300
  4. McVary KT. Clinical practice. Erectile dysfunction. New England Journal of Medicine, 2007. PubMed 18077811

Reviewed by PA Michael Rubio, US Medical Director

Seeing a doctor is as easy as sending a text

Concerned, need advice, a prescription, refill or referral?
Text a doctor now